I have three pet peeves about the Israeli-Arab conflicts. The first, is this notion that the Jewish nation is not an indigenous people to the Middle East, but rather some kind of European hybrid plant exported and planted in alien or foreign soil.
The second, is the notion that the United Nations created the state of Israel. The state of Israel was created by the blood and sweat of the nascent Israeli nation willing to fight to establish their right to self-determination in their ancestral homeland. The UN never rushed in to defend the state after David Ben-Gurion publicly declared the re-establishment of the Israeli state.
This Toronto Star article on Ariel Sharon touches on third peeve.
“The only way to respond (to attack) was by establishing new ground rules,” Gilad writes. “Jewish lives were not just for the taking; the harming of Jews was a crime that would be paid for.”Starting with the 1948 War of Independence, Sharon carved a wide swath through the Middle East, winning a starring role in its violent drama. At the height of his early popularity Sharon was Israel’s Spartacus, breaking the chains of oppression that had afflicted the Jews for centuries. Later he became “Arik, King of Israel.” But he also infuriated his superiors by following his own military doctrine of striking hard and fast, whatever the orders from above. His philosophy helped reshape the fledgling Israel Defense Forces from an inexperienced band to a crack commando army.
Do not misunderstand me, the Haganah were significantly under manned and under-armed given the far superior numbers of men and weaponry arrayed against them, but this idea, that the Haganah forces were an inexperienced band…is laughable and butt-ignorant.
At the time of War of Independence, Haganah forces numbered 20,000 – among the 20,000 troops were 4,000 Polish Jews; who were battle hardened and experienced in the finer arts of modern military warfare. Men who were forged in Rommel’s gardens are exactly who you want in your army when the military numbers/armaments game is stacked against you. Those Jews were made up with men like Jaques Bar, who received advanced military training at the Academy of Science in Moscow, and who later went on to learn the finer points of fighting and operating behind enemy lines where access to supplies and weapons was practically non-existent.
It was a wealth of experience which these 4000 Jews from the British Polish Corps II brought to the Haganah and the Palmach. I realize that the Labor Zionist myth has helped perpetrate the notion that the Haganah did not know how to ‘fight’, but given the reality, that the state of Israel fought its first official war as a state against armies of superior numbers and weapons but still prevailed…well, isn’t it time to give this myth a rest?
Of course, I would be remiss if I did not point out, that Sharon was far too young and far too low on the military ladder in the 40’s and early fifties to have had ‘his philosophy helped reshape the fledgling Israel Defense Forces. In fact, the ‘philosophy’ of the IDF was directly shaped by men like General Yitzhak Sadeh, and the men Sadeh hand picked to join the Palmach and lead its operations. Other than that, carry on.